How to Negotiate Your Salary: Scripts and Strategies That Actually Work

A 2023 survey found that only 37% of Americans always negotiate their salary when offered a new job. The other 63% accepted the first number. Given that a successful negotiation typically yields $5,000-$10,000 more annually — and that raise compounds through every future promotion and employer — this is one of the most expensive mistakes in personal finance.

The good news: salary negotiation is a learnable skill, and most hiring managers expect it.

Why Most People Don't Negotiate (and Why Those Reasons Are Wrong)

"I'm afraid they'll rescind the offer." Employers almost never rescind job offers for politely negotiating. They've invested weeks in your candidacy and won't start over because you asked for more money. In 15+ years of hiring research, this outcome is so rare it's essentially mythological for professional roles.

"I don't want to seem greedy." Asking for fair market compensation for your skills isn't greedy — it's how employment works. Hiring managers negotiate salaries professionally. They won't think less of you for it.

"I'm just grateful to get the offer." Gratitude is appropriate. Accepting artificially low compensation is not required to express it.

"I don't know what to ask for." This is the one with a real solution: research. More on this in a moment.

Research First: Know Your Market Value

Negotiating without data is guessing. Negotiating with data is strategy.

Primary research sources:

Collect 5-10 data points. Understand the range for your role, location, years of experience, and industry. Don't focus on a single number — understand the band.

Also research the specific company: Glassdoor and Blind often have salary data for specific companies, which is more relevant than national averages.

The insider move: If you've received other offers or are interviewing elsewhere, those are real data points. A competing offer is the most powerful negotiating lever available.

Negotiating a Job Offer: The Framework

When you receive a verbal offer, your immediate response should not be "yes" or "no." It should be a thoughtful pause and a request for time:

Initial response script:

"Thank you so much — I'm really excited about this opportunity. I'd love to take a couple of days to review the full details before responding. Can I get back to you by [specific date — no more than 2-3 business days]?"

This is universally accepted. Use those days to research, think through your priorities, and prepare your counter.

When you're ready to counter:

"I've given this a lot of thought, and I'm genuinely excited about joining the team. Based on my research into market rates for this role and the experience I bring, I was hoping we could get to [your target number]. Is there flexibility there?"

A few things are happening here:

• You express genuine enthusiasm (so they know you're not bluffing)
• You reference market data (so it's not arbitrary)
• You ask a question rather than making an ultimatum
• You're specific with a number

What number to ask for? Ask for 10-20% more than you'd genuinely accept. If the offer is $75,000 and you'd be happy with $82,000, ask for $85,000-$90,000. This gives you negotiating room. Most employers will meet somewhere in the middle.

Handling Common Responses

"The offer is at the top of the band."

"I understand there may be constraints. Would there be flexibility to revisit the salary after a 90-day review? Or is there flexibility in other areas — signing bonus, additional vacation, or an earlier performance review?"

"We don't have budget for that, but the role has a lot of growth opportunity."

"I appreciate that. Given the trajectory you're describing, could we put a performance review at 6 months with a specific salary target if I hit the milestones we define?"

"What were you making at your last job?"

In many states, employers are prohibited from asking about previous salary. But if they do ask:

"I prefer to focus on what this role is worth in the market and what my skills bring to the table. Based on my research and the scope of this position, I'm targeting [range]."

Or if you're comfortable sharing and it helps:

"My previous compensation was [$X], but I'm open to discussing what makes sense for this role."

"The offer is already very competitive."

"I really appreciate the offer, and I respect the process you've put into it. I've done a lot of research on market rates, and [specific reason — your experience, specialized skills, competing offers if applicable] leads me to believe [amount] would be appropriate. Would that be possible?"

Negotiating a Raise (Current Job)

Asking your current employer for a raise requires a different approach. You're not leveraging a competing offer (necessarily) — you're making a case based on your value and market conditions.

When to ask:

• Annual review cycle (natural timing)
• After a major accomplishment
• When you've taken on significantly more responsibility
• When you have documented market data showing you're underpaid
• When you have a competing offer (most powerful)

How to prepare:

Build a document before the conversation:

• Specific accomplishments from the past 12 months with measurable impact ($X in revenue, Y% improvement in process, Z projects delivered)
• Responsibilities added since your last salary adjustment
• Market data supporting your target salary
• Any feedback from managers or stakeholders about your performance

The conversation script:

"I wanted to set up some time to talk about my compensation. Over the past year, I've [specific accomplishments]. I've also taken on [additional responsibilities]. I've done some market research and found that roles with my experience and responsibilities at comparable companies are compensating in the range of [$X-$Y]. Given my contributions here, I'd like to discuss getting to [$target]."

If they say they can't do it now:

"I understand there may be budget constraints. Can we agree on a timeline for this conversation, and what specific milestones would support a compensation adjustment?"

Get the answer in writing (or follow up with an email summarizing what was agreed).

Beyond Base Salary: The Full Compensation Package

When negotiating, don't fixate only on base salary. The full compensation picture includes:

If they can't move on salary, ask what other components can move.

The Mindset Shift That Changes Everything

The most important reframe: salary negotiation is a business conversation, not a personal one.

The company isn't doing you a favor by offering you a job — they need your skills and they're competing for them. You're not asking for charity; you're establishing the price of a business relationship. Both sides have interests. Negotiation is how those interests get aligned.

Hiring managers negotiate salaries multiple times per year. For them, it's routine. Your nervousness about it is far larger than the situation warrants.

The worst realistic outcome is they say no and the offer stays the same. The best outcome is thousands of additional dollars per year for the rest of your career at that company. The expected value calculation is obvious.

Negotiate. Every time.

Enjoyed this guide? Subscribe to Frugal Rise — a free newsletter covering practical personal finance tips, delivered weekly.